Navigating conflict in dementia

Dementia is a broad term that encompasses a wide range of neurodegenerative disorders. It presents a great challenge, not only to the person diagnosed with dementia, but also to the family and those around them. People who work in the dementia field have education in how to manage the complex situations that can arise, and they train for and apply for those jobs. A family member usually does not have any preparation for what is unfolding in their home and the work of caring for the person arrives unheralded and unprepared for.  It’s an unwelcome surprise guest.

It is not unusual for conflict to emerge as a significant aspect of the dementia journey. This conflict can be the result of a wide range of factors. The stress of care-giving may cause a family member to be impatient or to be too tired to cope with what is presented to them. The person with dementia cannot help the changes in their level of anxiety, or changes in their mood and capacity to cope with everyday issues. It may become difficult for them to empathise with the carer, as they would normally have done all their lives.  Sometimes family say it is like living with a different person.  It’s not unusual for someone to say that the person has “died” as a metaphor meaning that it is as if they’ve lost the person they once loved. There will be more about this below.

A person with dementia who is struggling with cognitive impairment finds it difficult to understand the problems that are arising in their home. At the earliest stages, shame and stigma may make it difficult to discuss any of their problems with the people who might be able to help. Sometimes there is an instinctive pact between the people in the house to conceal that there is a problem from other family members or even statutory services. This arises from a fear of loss of control. The person may believe that interference from outside of the family will only make things worse. Denial as a mental mechanism is sometimes helpful for some situations but only if it is eventually worked through and replaced with action. When people try to behave as if nothing is going wrong it can make them ill.

Being positive is always important in any illness, but there is a term “toxic positivity” to describe an attitude which is not hopefulness or trying to make the best of things, but rather a position where problems are swept under the carpet.  The strain of pretending that you are OK when you are not OK is well-known. It is toxic when any attempt to consider difficulties is met with ferocious rage. Many carers can speak of how the person with dementia perks up for visitors and health professionals. They seem to draw on an inner strength for the duration of the visit, only to collapse with exhaustion after.  It can give rise to other family members and friends believing that the carer is imagining any problems.  “He looked fine to me. What do you think is her problem?” 

In order to help anyone with dementia, it’s important to realise that this conflict is real and can exist, but also that it can be resolved with help. There is enough to worry about when someone has dementia without carrying unnecessary mental effort. At the heart of conflict in dementia lies the progressive deterioration of cognitive functions. As the condition advances, individuals may experience memory loss, impaired judgment, and changes in personality and behaviour.

The cognitive decline disrupts the dynamics of decision-making and autonomy, fuelling tensions between individuals with dementia and their caregivers. Conflicts may arise over issues such as finances, medical care, driving, getting help in the home, and daily activities. Striking a balance between promoting autonomy and ensuring safety is fraught with disagreements and disputes.

An example is when the time has come for a person with dementia to give up driving.  One person may fear for their safety and the safety of other road users and pedestrians. It is often the case that the person with dementia is angry at this exercise of control over them.  They may find an ally in another family member who says it would be terrible for them to have to give up their car. It’s a battle that can leave scars on others long after the person with dementia is gone.

What can be done? Good communication is fundamental to good relationships. When someone has dementia there may be serious barriers to communication.  When it is harder to understand and express thoughts coherently, it’s very hard to avoid misunderstandings and conflict. It’s very frustrating, and you may feel helpless when you struggle to convey your intentions to someone who seems unable to understand. It’s important to be aware of what the person with dementia needs. It’s wrong to make them feel marginalised or belittled when decisions are made on their behalf with which they don’t agree.

This is why it is very important to have conversations long before verbal communication becomes challenging. It may be a comfort to be able to say that this person has said always that if they became a danger on the road, they would expect someone to take away their car keys. If when the day comes that person has dementia and is fighting against the idea of giving up driving, at least the family is able to say that they’re doing what he or she would have wanted. This does not mean that a person with dementia is unable to change their mind. Non-verbal communication such as body language and facial expressions can help you to understand what the person wants right to the end of life and many times it will be possible to make sure that they have that.  But on some decisions you may appear to be denying what they want.  Being sure of what they always said they would want helps reduce the guilt and conflict for the carer.  It is not only the person with dementia who has feelings of resentment and alienation. The caregivers may feel great tension among themselves if there is no bedrock on which they can rest their justification for decisions that they are trying to make in the interests of the person with dementia.

Caregiver burnout is characterised by exhaustion, resentment, and feelings of isolation and it is a pervasive issue that often exacerbates existing conflicts. Strained relationships, financial pressures, and a sense of guilt or obligation make things more difficult.  Most carers report that caring costs them their own money as well as the expenses for the person cared for.  That’s why it is important to make sure carers know about benefits and allowances available to them. But they can’t pick them up if the person affected is in denial about the need for diagnosis and the carer doesn’t self-identify as being in that role.  Moreover, conflicts may arise between family members or other caregivers regarding the division of responsibilities, decision-making authority, or differing approaches to care.

Strategies at this time include seeking support from others and setting realistic expectations. Which brings us back to the question about feeling that the loved one has “died” which was referred to above.  In March 2024 a dementia charity created a media storm with a campaign that spoke of dementia as a series of deaths, as if the person died with each loss – loss of ability to recognise loved ones, loss of skills and pleasures.  While it’s easy to see why this was shocking, the important message comes not from their advertisements but from the battle that erupted in its wake. This seemed to be between carers who could identify with this metaphor and others who utterly condemned the sorrowful and negative view of dementia. 

What they all had in common was an overwhelming desire to make things better, but they had different paths towards that goal.  This storm, which may turn out to have been a storm in a teacup, highlights that we can only make things better if we all work together on lots of strands – to research for a cure, to share ways of making life easier for carers, and to guarantee the rights of people with dementia.  The tension and conflict must be put aside as we are all walking along the same path in the end.

Professor June Andrews

(www.juneandrews.net)

Alzheimer's disease: the amyloid-beta peptide accumulates to amyloid fibrils that build up dense amyloid plaques
New Alzheimer's drugs: Hope, progress and difficult decisions
What is dementia
Whatever happened to the National Dementia Strategy?
Medical research laboratory. A scientist works with a pipette and a test tube
How close are we to a cure for Alzheimer's Disease?
iStock-1195554602-scaled-1
Preparing for Future Social Care
Mental health and problems with memory
What's New in Dementia Research: Beyond the Headlines
IMG-20260525-WA0017
A family fun day in memory of a hero
White woman talking on the phone and receiving bad news with a worried face
Supporting a Loved One with Dementia
from a Distance
Elderly woman with her caregiver at nursing home
How research is improving end of life care for people with dementia
coffee image 1
Thank you, St Mary's Coffee Shop
Trent Dementia article 'The ripple effect'
The ‘ripple effect’ – how small gestures can have long lasting impacts
rugby image
The Price of the Game
Sad husband feels sorry for his suffering senior wife, provides support and love
Grief Before and After Loss in Dementia
Senior asian couple having appointment with doctor for annual health check up program while the nurse is explaining the blood test result for healthy aging and longevity concept
Preparing for a Dementia Assessment:
What to Expect and How to Get Ready
Concept image of memory loss. Dementia or Alzheimer's
Trends in Dementia Research
Paint Splatter - Thank you
to Sahana Vaidyanathan
Grateful to have Christmas with You
Dementia at Christmas
Senior woman and her daughter looking at each other
Responding to Dementia without drugs
penguin golf
Thank you to the Penguins at Kettering Golf Club
Still Life Of Power Of Attorney Document On Desk
Why Powers of Attorney Matter, and What to Do if a Loved One Hesitates
Young woman hugging and comforting mother on sofa at home
Encouraging a Reluctant Loved One to See the Doctor About Dementia
Serious Senior Woman With Adult Daughter At Home
Why Families of People with Dementia need to Know about Delirium
MODELS_1767_2
Behind the scenes of our Online Store
Alarm clock in the middle of the night insomnia
Sleep and dementia
Image-What-is-dementia-blog-230525-scaled-1
What is Dementia?
Medical research laboratory. A scientist works with a pipette and a test tube
Is an Alzheimer Cure on the Horizon? What the Latest Dementia Medication Trials Are Telling Us
Brett Wayne Lee image 1
New song "Fade" coming out on 24th May
Young African American taking care of his old father in a wheelchair
Personal stories of living with dementia
Pensive elderly mature senior man looking in distance out of window, thinking of personal problems
Behavioural symptoms of dementia
Asian daughter spending time with her elderly mother at home
Five coping strategies for carers of people with dementia
iStock-1175583350-scaled
Family Dynamics and Dementia